Consistent Parenting: How to Unlock the Secret

by James Lehman, MSW
Consistent Parenting: How to Unlock the Secret

"Being consistent is the hardest thing of all," many parents tell us. And it's so true—it’s easy to lay down a rule and then let it slide when you’re tired or in a hurry. In this article, James Lehman explains why consistency is the key to your child’s behavior—and tells you ways to keep on track when you feel like giving up.

I don’t think beating yourself up is the answer to anything. I think that shame and remorse only make the problem worse; they only make you angrier on the inside as a person.

When your child is young, he starts to learn simple math. The way he learns is through a process called “rehearsal and repetition.” At first, simple addition and subtraction are the most alien concepts in the world to him. But slowly, he begins to understand that two and two equal four—and then he builds on that knowledge. Consistency is imperative. Look at it this way: what if two and two didn’t always make four? How would your child learn addition if the rules were always changing? If that was the case, he would never learn how to solve math equations correctly or adapt his learning to tackle more complex problems. This learning process is called “internalization” because your child takes it from the outside in; it becomes part of him on the inside. 

Related: How to use consequences effectively--and follow through.

Consistency is one of the main requirements for kids to learn how to predict things. In other words, I can predict that two and two equal four. Can I predict how my mother is going to act if I throw a tantrum? Can I predict how my father will react if I’m late for school? Can I predict how my parents are going to act if I don’t do my homework? Let’s face it, predictability is one of the foundations of our society—that’s why we’re disturbed when the trains don’t run on time or the post office isn’t open. For kids, inconsistency produces anxiety. Think of it this way: what if your boss was nice one day and mean the next? What if she said “good job” to you and then turned around and said “that’s unacceptable” after you performed the same task the exact same way? Or what if your employees showed up to work sometimes, but didn’t show up other times?

Kids need to be able to predict that two and two are going to be four the same way they need to be able to predict what time they’re going to go to bed, how they’re going to be dealt with if they curse, and what’s going to happen if they don’t do their homework. Consistency is a key learning tool for your child, because when something is consistent, he can rehearse it and incorporate it inside of himself until it becomes a part of him.

Let’s look at it this way. What if one day you don’t clean your room and your mother yells and screams at you to “get in there and pick things up”? And what if the next day, she’s in a hurry so she picks it up for you? And then, what if two days later she yells at you again? And then on Saturday, she picks it up for you because company is coming over. What are you learning?

Related: Lost your parental authority? How to get it back.

Most kids learn that if they put up with their mom yelling at them a little bit, eventually she’ll clean their room. The other thing that happens is that they don’t know how their parents are going to react; they’re effectively learning how to live with anxiety and chaos. They’re learning that the world is not predictable and adult responses can’t be gauged. As a result, different characteristics develop in different kids. Some become aggressive and hostile, while others become compliant and passive. All of them learn to deal with unpredictability, which again, creates anxiety. Kids have to develop the capacity to deal with anxiety when they’re young, so this can be overwhelming to their defenses. Sadly, they often wind up solving problems using inappropriate behavior.

Why Is Consistency the Hardest Thing for Most Parents?

Why is it so hard for parents to be consistent? First of all, parents are human. Unless we really push and train ourselves, I think it’s easy to get off track. To a parent, expediency often takes the place of consistency. It’s quicker to pick up your child’s room yourself when you’ve got company coming over than it is to get your son to take responsibility for it. Quite a few parents have told me things like, “I get so frustrated that my daughter won’t do what I’ve told her to do a thousand times that I start screaming at her.”

I also believe that many parents, through no fault of their own, don’t really have an understanding of how important consistency is. A majority of the families I saw in my therapy practice were in the dark about it, so I worked with them to give them the tools they needed. I said, “This what’s going on here: If you yell at your child for two days because he’s not doing his chores, then you do his chores for him the next two days, and the following day, you punish him, you’re going to raise a child who learns that nothing anyone does is predictable. And if things aren’t predictable and he can’t internalize problem-solving and social skills, he also won’t be able to internalize the values, knowledge and experiences that it will take to shape his behavior.”

Again, internalization, rehearsal and repetition—these are the keys to learning. Believe me, if the parents I worked with thought anything was hurting their kids, they would do their best to try to change it. But many saw inconsistency as just being human—and in a sense, they were right. They were overworked, overwhelmed and often exhausted. But the bottom line is that choosing expediency over consistency has an effect on your child’s behavior and character. The truth is, many children today are aggressive and destructive, and this emanates in part from inconsistent parenting.

Related: Fighting with your child all the time? How to stop the constant arguing.

It’s easy for parents to beat themselves up when they get this information. Maybe some social worker, psychologist or teacher is telling them that they’re not consistent enough at home. It’s easy to feel beat up, resentful, and overwhelmed. But the bottom line is, parents often blame themselves and feel like they’re not doing a good job. Sometimes they blame their child, or the counselor for not understanding what it’s like for them.

But here’s the deal: I don’t think beating yourself up is the answer to anything. I think that shame and remorse only make the problem worse; they only make you angrier on the inside as a person. 

I understand that parents do get worn down; often they’ll try to be consistent, but if they don’t see change right away, they give up. Personally, I think giving up after a few days or weeks is one of the biggest mistakes you can make as a parent. Changing a behavior takes a long time and it takes consistent application of new principles and ideas in order for kids to incorporate them on the inside. And until then, your child needs a parent to structure his life and set limits on him, because he’s a kid—not a little adult. Children don’t think like adults, they don’t see the world the same way as adults do, and they don’t experience things the way we do.

A young child’s mind works very differently from ours, and so does an adolescent’s. Until their early twenties, kids’ minds are constantly shifting and changing in the way they operate. If you talk to a guy who’s 21, he usually wants the same thing as a kid who’s 16 does: a car, an apartment, a girlfriend, a stereo system. He hasn’t changed very much; he’s not yet an adult. If you talk to that same person when he’s 30, he’ll say he wants security and predictability. Perhaps he wants a career that’s worthwhile, or wants to make some money. He’s thinking about saving money, investing in things, and his future. Most 22 year olds aren’t thinking along those lines yet because their brains are still developing.

Related: Feeling at the end of your rope? How to be a calm parent.

What You Can Do to Become More Consistent

Rely on Simple, Concrete Ideas: It’s so important to keep it as simple as possible. For instance, I used to have parents write down the rules that they thought were appropriate, and then we’d go over them. Afterward, they would start to follow what they had written down at home. This is effective because then it isn’t left up to your imagination or to memory. You have a list. I would ask parents to consider the following and supply me with an answer:

  • What time is bed time?
  • What time is hygiene time in the bathroom?
  • What time is homework time?
  • What are the rewards?
  • What are the consequences?

All of these rules were written down on a piece of yellow paper, and then the parents began to incorporate them. I advised parents to read this list out loud to themselves every morning. Some thought that was crazy. They’d say, “How can I do that? I’ll feel stupid.” But the concept of rehearsal and reinforcement is important with parenting, too.  As a parent, you need to rehearse this new information. The process of reading it out loud reinforces your new techniques and rules. Then you put them into practice. The day will come when you don’t need to read your list out loud, because you’ll be living it. It’s a simple tool but it’s one thing I teach parents in order to help them be more consistent.

Get the Support You Need: If you don’t understand how important consistency is and you don’t know how to apply it on a regular basis in your home, you need to get help. There are parenting programs, classes, support groups and professionals out there who can help you.

Setting Down the New Rules

Parents ask me if they should sit down with their kids immediately and tell them what the new household rules are. I think that the last thing that you want to do is make a big announcement to your kids about all the changes that will be taking place, and then not follow through. What tends to happen is that you’ll feel better for a little bit, but then when you don’t follow through, it falls apart. Instead, the first thing you should do is start instituting your new rules.

Expect resistance, depending upon the age of your child. If they’re five or six years old, expect tantrums. If your children are older, expect arguments and door-slamming. Although it might not feel like it at the time, these are all signs that your new techniques are working. Your child might push back, but stick to your guns.

After you start to successfully implement the new laws in your home, you can begin to talk to your kids about the changes. If you have a pre-adolescent or teen in the house, I think it is important to sit down when things are going well and say, “I’m going to be doing things more consistently from now on. I haven’t really followed through and I’m not comfortable with the way I’ve been setting the rules down. So from now on, curfew means curfew. If you come in two minutes after curfew or one minute after curfew, there will be consequences. If you come in on curfew or before, there will be a reward—and the rewards is that you get to go out again next Saturday night. Your room has to be clean by this time. Homework has to be done by this time. Your grades have to be maintained at this level in order for you to drive or to go out on the weekends at night.”

Related: "Learning how to behave appropriately is a problem-solving skill."—James Lehman

The older the child, the more resistance you will face. Expect to be tested. In fact, whether your child is four or fourteen, expect to be tested. Above all, don’t give in— the testing will diminish in time.

The other thing you need to ask yourself is, “Are my expectations realistic? Am I being consistent about the right things?” If you’re being consistent about a seven o’clock bedtime for a young child, that’s great. If you’re being consistent about a seven o’clock bedtime for a 13-year-old, I think you should take another look at that.

Remember, parenting, just like childhood, is a dynamic that keeps developing. It takes constant readjustments, flexibility and firmness. In the end, there is no “secret” to consistency—it’s just the willingness of a parent to take the time to stick to the rules they’ve laid out for their child. The benefits of consistent parenting are that your child will internalize your rules and values over time and learn to do things with simple reminders rather than conflict.


Enter your email address to receive our FREE
weekly parenting newsletter.

James Lehman, MSW was a renowned child behavioral therapist who worked with struggling teens and children for three decades. He created the Total Transformation Program to help people parent more effectively. James' foremost goal was to help kids and to "empower parents."


I'm a very tird mother of 6.The advice in this article is definately getting implimented in my home!I know that what he recommends is sound becouse other things he's reccomended have helped me so much! Thank you for helping families help themselves.

Comment By : Lisa

This is very helpful advice and I will be implementing it TODAY!

Comment By : japntap

I appreciate the examples and suggestions you've provided. I've written about the topic and it's one of the harder things to change about parenting.

Comment By : Marcia Stein, PHR

Being consistant is easy when you are full of energy; when your tired it's harder but still a MUST!

Comment By : Jackie

Another thing you can do to make it easier to be consistent is to POST rewards & consequences. Write them on a big poster for all to see. As a teacher, when I did this in my classroom, it made it easier for me to be consistent. (Teachers have the same problem with being consistent too.) Teachers also know that when they get lazy, the students really take advantage of the inconsistency. Then things get harder. In the long run, 100% consistency makes life easier.

Comment By : May

the articles written here have been very helpful to me as I am the mother of three,two teen girls and a twelve yr old boy with behavioral issues that we have been trying to get a handle on.thanks so much!

Comment By : shelly

Parents frequently tell me they cannot be consistent and are typically "beating themselves up" over that. My response is that only machines can be absolutely consistent, but that humans/parents can be persistent. Keep the goals and limits clear and get back on track -- be persistent. This usually helps recover the motivation.

Comment By : JP, MSW

Consistency is something I need to work on. I sometimes allow my kids to eat in the family room. I usually regret it due to the mess they leave.

Comment By : Cindy

I think it is also hard to know what the consequences should be sometimes ! So sometimes my husband doesn't do anything !( Like when chores are not done ,or she is mean to her sisters )

Comment By : Amber

What do you do when the parents are divorced? My boyfriend has the most difficult time becasue he stays consistent with the kids at our house but their mother does not at all. They are learning that they can do whatever they want at mom's but not at dad's. In turn, they want to spend less time with us because they are held accountable for their actions in our home. Of course, this makes their mom happy so she does not change or even listen to reason. The kids are failing, being expelled. We just don't know what to do. Please help!

Comment By : cdp

I am a single mother of 3 and I have been very inconsistant throughout my parenting. I lost my husband (their father) to cancer 5 1/2 years ago and things have been really tough. I want so badly to be more consistant, but is it ever too late to start? My kids ages are 18, 15 and 8.

Comment By : Melissa

Like all "right" things in life - hard to do.

Comment By : eugene

* Dear Melissa: It’s never too late to make changes or add more consistency to your life. Not only will your kids have an increased ability to know what to expect from you, you probably will feel less stress if you are working within a system of schedules, rules, and expectations. Work on changing one behavior at a time so your kids—and you—are not feeling overwhelmed, but instead they stay focused on the skills needed to change a particular behavior. When that first behavior change is accomplished, challenge the kids to work on the next one. In Lesson 3 of the Total Transformation Program, James Lehman teaches in detail the techniques for effective parenting and creating a ‘culture of accountability’ in your home. Change will take time. Be patient with yourself and the kids as you go through this process and call us here on the Support Line for encouragement. We’re here to help.

Comment By : Carole Banks, Parental Support Line Advisor

* Dear ‘cdp’: It takes a lot of work and patience to “blend” a new family. In cases of divorce with children, you’re also learning how to interact with an ex-spouse. What James Lehman, author of the Total Transformation Program recommends is that you only focus on what takes place in your own home and not what occurs in the other home. In other words, don’t allow the kids to play one parent against the other or put them in the middle by asking about what happens when they visit their Mom. Kids are capable of learning different rules for different settings, just as they do for home and for school. If the kids try to argue that their Mom allows them to do something that they are not allowed to do at your home, don’t criticize the Mom, of course, but simply say, “You may be allowed to do that at your Mom’s house, but in this house, these are the rules.” Hold the kids responsible for their behavior choices when they’re in your home. For more information on the challenges of divorce, refer to Lesson 5 of the Total Transformation Program and this article by Carri and Gordon Taylor: Blended Family? The 5 Secrets of Effective Step parenting We appreciate your question and wish your family the best.

Comment By : Carole Banks, Parental Support Line Advisor

By far the most important piece of parenting advice I've heard, and definitely my Achilles heel. I think that even poor rules, enforced consistently, would produce better adjusted kids than the norm.

Comment By : cm


Comment By : moxie

Rate this article by clicking the stars below.

Rating: 2.7/5 (172 votes cast)

Related keywords:

consistent parenting, methods, advice, discipline

Responses to questions posted on are not intended to replace qualified medical or mental health assessments. We cannot diagnose disorders or offer recommendations on which treatment plan is best for your family. Please seek the support of local resources as needed. If you need immediate assistance, or if you and your family are in crisis, please contact a qualified mental health provider in your area, or contact your statewide crisis hotline.

We value your opinions and encourage you to add your comments to this discussion. We ask that you refrain from discussing topics of a political or religious nature. Unfortunately, it's not possible for us to respond to every question posted on our website.
If you like "Consistent Parenting: How to Unlock the Secret", you might like these related articles: