Why Consequences Aren't Enough, Part 1: How to Coach Your Child to Better Behavior

by Sara Bean, M.Ed.
Why Consequences Aren't Enough, Part 1: How to Coach Your Child to Better Behavior

Do you feel stuck in a cycle with your child where his behavior isn’t changing—and might actually be getting worse? Many parents think that simply giving consequences should be enough to fix misbehavior. These same parents often end up feeling defeated and are left wondering why the consequences didn’t work. In this two-part series, Sara Bean explains the key to changing kids’ behavior (and it’s not consequences). Read on to learn how to parent your child more effectively, starting today.

"You’ll be giving consequences but will be not seeing any change—stuck in this cycle like a hamster on a wheel until you start to see your role as a parent differently."

Do you use consequences with your kids and wonder why their behavior isn’t changing? Many parents mistakenly think that consequences alone are enough to discipline children effectively, but they’re not. Many parents also believe that for a consequence to be effective, it has to make their child completely miserable. Parents will call the Parental Support Line and say, “I really can’t find a consequence that my teen cares about; nothing stings enough to make him stop acting this way.” As James Lehman said, “You can’t punish kids into better behavior.” Some parents think that kids learn solely by experiencing an unpleasant outcome, but that’s not usually the case. In my opinion, many parents are overly focused on consequences as their primary discipline technique. If this is you, you’ll be giving consequences but will not be seeing any changestuck in this cycle like a hamster on a wheel until you start to see your role as a parent differently.  You’ll be doing all sorts of hard work and using up a lot of energy, but not really getting anywhere.

Related: It’s not just about consequences—find out what you need to do to be an effective parent.

James Lehman’s three effective parenting roles lay the foundation for holding kids accountable by giving parents the necessary perspective and skills they need to teach their kids better ways to behave. Let’s be clear: we mean “teaching” here in quite a literal way. We want our kids to learn new skills, what James called “replacement behaviors.” For example, if you have a child who typically gets verbally abusive when you ask him to do chores, you need to teach him another way of handling things instead of calling you foul names or screaming at you. What it really comes down to is this: you can tell your child to stop doing something until you’re blue in the face. You can take away any and every privilege they have for weeks or months at a time, but if they don’t know what to do instead—or even understand what else is acceptable—the negative, abusive behaviors are just going to continue, and you’re going to become more and more frustrated and exhausted.

The Three Parenting Roles

In The Total Transformation Program, James Lehman identifies three effective parenting roles that we all need to take on with our kids. Committing to taking on these roles is one of the most important steps to stopping undesirable behaviors and making positive changes in your family and home life. By the way, when he talks about roles, he doesn’t mean the kind of role an actress plays in a movie, where she’s just pretending to be somebody else—he means a functional purpose which you fulfill or assume in your life. These roles are:

  • The Trainer/Coach
  • The Problem Solver
  • The Limit Setter

They can be seen as three different sets of helpful skills that you can practice and use together to influence your child’s behavior. It’s important that you incorporate all three on a daily basis, transitioning from one to the other as needed. Be aware that you might be a Limit Setter at one moment and later shift into Problem Solver mode. You don’t want to simply choose one of these roles and become rigid, getting stuck in it for a long period of time without using the other two roles; this won’t be effective. The three roles go together and must be blended and balanced. I’ve talked to many parents who told me that with time and practice, they were able to use all three roles with ease. Today I’m going to tell you more about the critical Trainer/Coach role.

The Trainer/Coach

When you’re playing the part of the trainer and coach, you’re going to be focused on teaching your child a skill she needs to be successful in life. The Trainer/Coach role asks you to look at where your child is right now. Ask yourself, “What is my child currently able to do?” and coach her forward from there rather than starting at a level higher than what your child can manage. After all, you wouldn’t sit your three-year-old down one day and expect her to write her name all on her own without teaching her first. It’s just not a realistic expectation. Breaking a big, hard task into smaller, more manageable steps is important. Instead of focusing on immediate results and trying to achieve an ideal of perfection, start where your child is and move forward.

Make sure the ideals you’d like your child to reach are attainable for her. Remember, as James says, “You have to parent the child you have, not the child you wish you had.” A parent using the Trainer/Coach role understands that children will struggle—and that many times you need to let them struggle. They will experience some discomfort and unpleasant feelings and that’s okay; it’s a necessary part of growing into a responsible adult.

Related: Find out the secret of giving consequences that work.

Here’s a scenario to show you what I mean. Let’s say a softball coach sees a player having trouble hitting the ball. The child swings and misses, hits a foul ball, and eventually strikes out. The coach doesn’t get in there and say, “Give me that bat; I’ll do it for you.” The coach lets the player get through the situation, lets her feel sad or angry about it and then talks to the player later and says something like, “I know you really want to hit the ball. Here’s what I saw you doing that isn’t helpful; try it this way instead. If you keep trying, you’ll get this. We’ll work on this more at practice tomorrow.” So kids need practice and repetition at home too, just like we do as parents. They need to strike out several times in order to really start to learn new ways of handling their problems. And they need you to let them strike out in most cases. Remember, repetition leads to success.

Let’s put this in terms of something that might happen at home. Let’s say your tween is demanding that you take her to the mall, but her room is a disaster. An ineffective way to handle that might be, “How dare you talk to me that way! I’m not going to drive you to the mall with an attitude like that. And on top of that, your room is still a mess. Since you didn’t clean it today like you were supposed to, you’ve lost your computer for a week.” In contrast, the Trainer/Coach might say, “I want you to be able to go to the mall. Here’s what isn’t helping you. I heard you tell me in a loud voice to drive you to the mall and I see that your room is still very messy. There are still clothes, shoes, and books all over the floor. So here’s what you can do instead. You can clean your room, put your clothes away, and put the books back on the shelf, and then come back and ask me if I will drive you to the mall in a quieter voice. That’s how you can get what you want.”

In part two of this series, Sara Bean will explain more about the Problem Solver and Limit Setter Roles, and how to use all three roles to parent your child more effectively to help them change their behavior. Please check your inbox next week for Part 2 of “Why Consequences Aren’t Enough” from EmpoweringParents.com.


Enter your email address to receive our FREE
weekly parenting newsletter.

Sara A. Bean, M.Ed. holds a Masters Degree in Education with a concentration in School Counseling from Florida Atlantic University. She is a Certified School Counselor and a proud aunt to a 5 year-old girl. She has been with Legacy Publishing since 2009 working on the Parental Support Line. Sara has over 5 years of experience working with youth and families in private homes, residential group homes, and schools.

READER'S COMMENTS

This makes so much sense. Once you accept where your child is instead of where they "should" be, and then coach them forward, you do get results. We've been there with our son. It's hard to change your approach in the heat of the moment, but it's so worth the extra effort.

Comment By : KL

I have been a karate teacher for over 37 years. I currently teach 400 children every week. I incorporate a lot of "Empowering Parents" ideas in my classes. I always enjoy learning new ways to motivate & educate students and my own children.

Comment By : NASKA#1

Great advice. I think a few more examples of dialogue would be really helpful.

Comment By : Gran

This is good overall, but the example makes you think you have to have a carrot for every good action, that is bribery, not parenting.

Comment By : eugene

We do like our children to be happy but going to the mall costs money. I would need to say the stuff about the room but not and how to ask but not leave it that if they ask quietly and sweetly, we can go. I would have to say, "When you are able to put away your ... and have cleaned the room and can approach me quietly and respectfully, I will be willing to neotiate about a fun activity for or with you Shirley

Comment By : Shirley

I want you to know how much I appreciate your counsel... I'm amazed at how much LESS effort it takes and how much MORE is accomplished applying your sugeestions!

Comment By : entheos22

Oh boy, from your mouth to her ears! Awesome approach. Will try it next time and pray for inspiration and control in choosing the right words.

Comment By : Kat

i LIKE THIS APPROACH IF THE KIDS REALLY WANT THEIR REQUEST MET THEY WILL COMPLY.

Comment By : dsp

Why Consequences Aren't Enough, Part I is clear and precise advise that makes logical since. Thank you.

Comment By : js

WE ARE FOSTER CARERS IN THE UK AND WE HAVE LEARNED MORE FROM OUR LOOKED AFTER CHILDREN THAN YOU CAN IMAGINE I FIND THE ADVICE ON HOW TO DEAL WITH PROBLEM BEHAVIOUR IS INVALUABLE TO ACHEIVE A CALM HOME I LIKE THE FACT THAT SOLUTUIONS ARE OFFERED THE AMAZING CHILDREN I HAVE LOOKED AFTER DESERVE EVERY EFFORT IT TAKES TO HELP BUILD SELF CONTOL AND SELF ESTEEM THANK YOU AND KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK

Comment By : lwel

All this talk of how effectively parent makes me realize I am not fit to be a parent. thought I might be but it is clear I have no business being a parent. My wife have both been willing to work hard to get our lifes to where they are now. Most kids don't get it that it takes effort and persistence to get the life or results they say they want. They only kinda want things. It's rare to see a kid really go after what they say they want. When he's 18, he's outta here and good riddance.

Comment By : Saving my energy

These few suggestions make very good sense. I look forward to learning more

Comment By : flyingvog

Rate this article by clicking the stars below.

Rating: 3.2/5 (111 votes cast)

Related keywords:

Consequences, Child Behavior, Behave, Trainer, Coach, Problem solver, Limit Setter, Setting Limits

Responses to questions posted on EmpoweringParents.com are not intended to replace qualified medical or mental health assessments. We cannot diagnose disorders or offer recommendations on which treatment plan is best for your family. Please seek the support of local resources as needed. If you need immediate assistance, or if you and your family are in crisis, please contact a qualified mental health provider in your area, or contact your statewide crisis hotline.

We value your opinions and encourage you to add your comments to this discussion. We ask that you refrain from discussing topics of a political or religious nature. Unfortunately, it's not possible for us to respond to every question posted on our website.
If you like "Why Consequences Aren't Enough, Part 1: How to Coach Your Child to Better Behavior", you might like these related articles: