ADHD: Disorder or Difference?

by Dr. Robert Myers, Child Psychologist
ADHD: Disorder or Difference?

The word “disorder” conjures up images of illness, disease and serious disabilities.  All parents want to see their child as the smartest, most capable and best liked boy or girl on the block.  So why would they want to have a label attached to them that often coveys just the opposite--such as slow learner, under-achiever or Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder?

What a difference one word can make.  Suppose we changed the last D in ADHD from “disorder” to “difference.”  We could then say that a child with ADHD has some significant differences in his cognitive ability, emotional sensitivity and activity level when compared to other children.  This difference is probably inherited.  His “skill set” is different from 95% of the children in his class.

I believe that, as a society, we have created a monster with ADHD, and it has fueled our perception that medicating our children can solve all their problems-and ours.

Unfortunately, the environment in which he spends most of his time is geared toward the other 95%.  However, we then could look at helping him to adapt successfully to this environment, using his own set of strengths rather than helping him to cope with this environment due to his weaknesses.  We then might say that this child may need psychostimulants and/or psychological intervention to enable him to concentrate on boring tasks and control spontaneity in a highly regimented environment.

The above in some ways reflects the ongoing debate about whether ADHD is a valid mental health condition that requires appropriate medical and psychological intervention OR that ADHD is a mythical disease state, manufactured by the medical community in order to make huge profits and is promoted by educational bureaucrats and abusive parents desiring to tranquilize unruly kids. I believe that, as a society, we have created a monster with ADHD. We perceive it as a diagnosis that will forever change or even taint the course of our child’s life. And we are no longer surprised by the number of school-age children who are now diagnosed with ADHD. In fact, we have come to regard it as a norm, and it has fueled our perception that medicating our children can solve all their problems—and ours.  

The facts, as in most debates, point to the truth being somewhere in the middle of these perceptions.  ADHD is a condition worthy of future study to provide answers to scientific questions that will result in more accurate diagnosis and more effective methods of treatment. In the meantime, ADHD left untreated leads to a higher likelihood of depression, suicide and substance abuse later in life.  ADHD appropriately treated leads to a higher likelihood of success in life because it can help the child properly channel his increased sensitivity, creativity and high energy.

On a more personal level, as a parent of a son who was diagnosed with ADHD at the age of five, I can identify with parents who may lean toward either the denial or victim mentality.  When my wife and I were concerned about our son’s behavior and emotional well-being, the last thing I thought of was that he had ADHD.  Sometimes, I was probably a bit on the overprotective side.  But on the whole, once our whole family accepted that he was a child with an attention deficit hyperactivity difference who needed medication, along with psychological support (provided by us at home), the situation turned around completely.  He responded well to the medication, and the crisis of emotional turmoil was over.  Over the years, we continued to provide consistent structure (as best we could) and encouragement as well as teaching him how to relax, learn necessary social skills and how to “stop and think.”  It all paid off.  He has been off medication since middle school.  He graduated with honors from a highly regarded university and is now pursuing a successful career in TV and film.  He has a great sense of humor and lots of friends.

I encourage parents not be afraid of the diagnosis, give it undue weight and importance or use the label as a crutch for your child. Instead, I believe we need to accept it as the first step in turning a difficult situation around to a positive direction.  Helping a child with ADHD succeed requires a team approach that often needs to continue over many years.  That team includes the family, health professionals, teachers and, of course, the child.  Children may need medication, but treatment guidelines indicate that psychological interventions are also important.  In some cases, psychological interventions may be sufficient to bring about desired results. In other cases, they address symptoms medication alone does not help and may also actually reduce the dosage of medication necessary to achieve desired results. 

Effective psychological interventions include parent education, behavior modification, home-school contracts, cognitive behavioral therapy, social skills training, relaxation training and mental exercises to improve cognitive functioning.   Recent research indicates that many or all of these interventions may be most effective when implemented at home with the parents and the child working as a team.  Not only does this approach appear to improve the short-term effectiveness of the interventions, it also results in positive parenting techniques and an open and supportive parent/child relationship that becomes a way of life that is consistent and enduring over time.

So, ADHD can be perceived as a label to be dreaded, used as an excuse to avoid difficult situations or it can be perceived as the identification of the problem underlying a child’s difficulties at home and at school which can be successfully addressed.  On the one hand, it is a curse. On the other, it is an opportunity to make things better. The basic tenet of cognitive behavioral therapy is that how we think determines how we feel, which then determines how we behave.  If we want to change how we feel and how we behave as the result of those feelings, we need to change how we think.   ADHD: Think of it as an opportunity.


      

Enter your email address to receive our FREE
weekly parenting newsletter.

Dr. Robert Myers is a clinical psychologist with 25 years of experience working with children and adolescents with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder and learning disabilities, and is the creator of The Total Focus Program. Dr. Bob has been a talk show host on KIEV and KORG in Southern California and has also appeared as a guest on many radio and television talk shows nationally and as a regular columnist for Parents and Kids Magazine. Dr. Myers earned his PhD from the University of Southern California.

READER'S COMMENTS

I have my son diagnosed with inactive ADD. He is 15 going on 16 years old. I feel on the middle of nowhere. How can I be helpful besides giving him the medication? I register him for summer class of Learning skills. Hopefuly this will improve his next school year. But I feel like need to do some more .....activities, socializing and ect.

Comment By : Tatiana K.

I have to say this is a valid discussion. I have a child with ADHD and he was not on medication for a long time. I wanted to exercise all other options before I had him "labeled" as ADHD. He is now taking medication and it has really helped. Our children are being processed as labels and not individuals with individual needs. My son is almost too intelligent and he has a loving nature. He is not overly aggressive or rude. He has shown a learning disability that has not been officially diagnosed yet. His learning type is more oral than written. Our children deserve to be treated as "normal" kids not "labels."

Comment By : donna stewart

I've told my son that ADD was named before it was truly understood. It's not that he has a deficit or disorder, but that he directs attention differently that most people. For us, ADD means Attention Direction Differences. Neither a good nor bad thing, it is just a different way of being.

Comment By : tbennett

my daughter is in 5th grade, she' been diagnosed with ADHD, and her weakness' are Math and Language Arts, she also says that she likes History but is boring. Her passion Science. The problems: she goes to a christian school, the school made modifications and the child study team accepted them, but left the application of them to the school, there's no variation on the grading criteria (meaning she is been evaluated as a regular student), the teacher's, principal and school don't want to change anything because they use the word "as a traditon" all the time when I ask for something. There's only 6 children in the classroom and the teacher keeps saying that she is the only one that doesn't get it. I'm a teacher and as an educator I ask for every single thing I think of. I found very interesting that Dr. Myers is able to help parents like us. My daughter is not aggressive, but sometimes she just spits whatever comes to her mind specially if it bothers her. I have a hard time with homework (4-5 hours), practicing the famous Spelling. The teachers only give 2 grades Homework and tests. She receives in class support 2 times a week and she still doesn't know her multiplication tables, resulting on a lot of gaps in Math (even though she's been in the same school for the last 3 years) and me paying for a tutor. I have to change her to another school. Do you think is a good idea if I change her to another school right now before the first marking period is over and put her in a different environment with more students in the classroom (she's never been in a public school)? I will appreciate every answer or comment related to our concerns.

Comment By : nana06

* Hi nana06: It sounds like you are very concerned with how your daughter’s school has been implementing the modifications suggested for her classroom. Ultimately, it is your decision when and whether to remove her from her current school. What you can do now is be an advocate for your daughter. Schedule a meeting with your daughter’s teacher, the principal, and the special education coordinator for her school so you can voice your concerns. After that meeting, follow up with a memo regarding what was discussed and agreed upon. If there are no accommodations made for your daughter as a result of the meeting, start going to higher authorities, such as the superintendent, or the board of education. Make a file of all written correspondence (letters, evaluations, etc) regarding your daughter and her required modifications, and reference this when scheduling with other authorities. I am attaching an article you might find helpful: How to Navigate the School System When Your Child Has a Disability Good luck to you as you continue to advocate for your daughter.

Comment By : Rebecca Wolfenden, Parental Support Advisor

Rate this article by clicking the stars below.

Rating: 2.6/5 (85 votes cast)

* All fields are mandatory.

Submit Comment:


Your Email (Will not be shown):


Screen Name (Will appear next to comment):


Please enter the text in the image:
captcha image  



Your comment will be posted after it is approved by the EP site administrator.
Related keywords:

ADHD/ADD, Medication, School-related problems, Coping Skills, Effective Parenting, behavior problems, James Lehman, The Total Transformation Program, Total Focus, Robert Myers, Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder

Responses to questions posted on EmpoweringParents.com are not intended to replace qualified medical or mental health assessments. We cannot diagnose disorders or offer recommendations on which treatment plan is best for your family. Please seek the support of local resources as needed. If you need immediate assistance, or if you and your family are in crisis, please contact a qualified mental health provider in your area, or contact your statewide crisis hotline.
If you like "ADHD: Disorder or Difference?", you might like these related articles:
The Total Transformation Program