Newsletter Signup

emailEnter your email address to receive our FREE weekly parenting newsletter
  View Email Archive

Latest blog Posts

Control Freak vs. Pushover Parenting:
Why Neither Works

by Debbie Pincus, MS LMHC
Control Freak vs. Pushover Parenting: Why Neither Works

A recent article by self–described “Tiger Mom” Amy Chua ignited a parenting conversation that appears to have been long overdue. In both the article and her book, Chua says she did not accept any grade  less than an “A” from her two daughters, and did not allow T.V., video games, playdates or sleep–overs. Chua believes typical Western style parenting is too lax and focuses on self–esteem over performance. The ongoing debate her article caused has led many parents to wonder if they’re too passive—or too controlling.

Your child needs you to think for yourself and express your thoughts, beliefs and values. This helps him do the same for himself later.

Whether you have the tendency to be a control freak or a doormat, your intentions are most likely good ones. You love and care about your child, and want him to be successful and happy. But when some parents get anxious about their kids—and their daunting parental responsibility—they manage their anxiety by controlling their kids. Other parents give their children free rein and try to be their kids’ friend rather than their parent. Unfortunately, neither style will help your child launch into an independent adult who can stand on his own two feet. The key to being an effective parent is finding a reasonable, loving balance between the two extremes.

Related: Are you at the end of your parenting rope?

Are You a Control Freak Parent?

If your morning routine sounds like this, you are probably a control freak parent: “Get down for breakfast this minute. You need to brush your teeth now. Go back to your room and put on the red sweater instead—it looks better with that outfit. You should ask your teacher for help as soon as you get to school today.” Controlling parents typically use lots of “shoulds” and “shouldn’ts.”

A parent who micromanages their child’s life will answer “yes” to one or more of these questions:

  • Must it be your way and only your way? Are you always right?
  • Do you threaten, lecture, warn, or order your kids around in a barking kind of tone?
  • Do you often do things your child can do for himself because you think you can do it better or “the right way?”
  • Do you tend to make decisions for your child? Do you often use bribes to get him to do what you want him to do?
  • Do you give him little freedom to think for himself?

Or…Are You a Pushover Parent

You may be the type of parent who goes to the opposite extreme. If you are more of a pushover parent, you’ll find yourself frequently saying things like, “Okay, well maybe just this one time,” or “You never listen to me anyway, so go ahead and do what you want."

Here are some questions you can ask yourself to determine if you’re a passive parent:

  • Do you want to make sure your child never struggles, fails or feels pain or disappointment?
  • Do you feel bad saying “no” to him?
  • Do you find yourself nagging your child and rewarding everything he does?
  • Do you try to be your child’s friend more than his parent?
  • Do you do for him what he can do for himself? Do you generally over–function for him and at times feel resentful?
  • Do you make your focus your child instead of yourself and your adult relationships?
  • Are you kind of afraid of your child?

Related: Afraid of confronting your child?

Control Freaks vs. Pushovers: Why Neither Parenting Style Works

The problem with being overly controlling as a parent is that when you try to control your child (or anyone for that matter) you will most likely cause them to assume a position of chronic defensiveness. Your child will fight for his autonomy—which is actually a healthy, normal developmental response on his part. If you parent this way, as soon as you need something from your child—cooperation, respect, love, good behavior, good manners—you put yourself in a vulnerable position. You think you are in control, but actually you have handed your child the control. If you need a certain behavior from your child, all he has to do is refuse to give it to you. Now you are at a loss, feeling anxious and out of control.

The struggle for control begins and never ends. The issue, whether it’s turning off the computer or taking the garbage out, becomes secondary to the bigger issue of who is going to win that struggle. Your child becomes so caught up in keeping control over his life that his energy goes into defending himself rather than thinking about good choices for himself. So you’ll have conversations like the following:

You: “Please read your book.”
Your child: “I already did.”
You: “I didn’t see you read it today.”
Your child: “Well I did.”
You: “No you didn’t.”
Your child: “Yes I did.”
You: “No you didn’t.”

This argument, as you can see, is never ending. On the other hand, when you’re a pushover parent, you’re bending over backwards to make sure your child feels good at all costs. You probably find yourself saying things like the following:

“If you’re too tired to shovel the snow, don’t worry about it.” Or “That science project looks really difficult. I’ll help you with it”—and then you find yourself doing the whole thing.  The pushover parent will also simply do things that the child is supposed to do, often feeling resentful about it, or give in easily to whining and pleading.

When parents are too passive, kids get lost because there are no adults home; children flounder in this atmosphere because they have no leader to properly guide them and hold them accountable.

Related: Learn how to hold your child accountable.

To put it simply, your child needs parents who have a solid sense of self. Your child doesn’t need parents who become what he wants them to become; your child needs you to think for yourself and express your thoughts, beliefs and values. This helps him do the same for himself later. Keep in mind that when your kids give you a hard time, they are testing you. On a deeper level, they really don’t want you to give in to them. They want to know that their parents are sturdy and not wishy–washy.

And when you know who you are as a parent, you won’t become “fused” with your kids; you won’t need to be liked or validated by them in some way. The result is that your children won’t be burdened with taking emotional care of you; they will be free to grow up.

How to Find the Right Balance

So what does it look like to be a parent who can combine the “rule side” of parenting—James Lehman’s Limit Setting role—with the “loving side” of being a parent? The solution is to enforce reasonable rules while doing it in a loving and empathetic way.

Basically, you want to give your child choices to help him to develop his own guidelines as he matures. Offer and look for opportunities for your child to make his own decisions and mistakes, and allow him to be disappointed—and even to fail—when he makes bad choices.

Related: How to give consequences that work.

I also firmly believe that you need to hold your child accountable for his actions—don’t step in and rescue him, but on the other hand, don’t manage everything so he never has to make those tough choices. I also tell parents “Let reality rather than reactivity be your child’s guide.” For example, let’s say your 13–year–old daughter sits down to breakfast and says, “Yuck, I don’t like eggs. I’m not going to eat them.” The control freak parent would say “Yes, you are going to eat the eggs and you won’t leave the table until you do.” In contrast, the pushover parent might say, “I’m sorry you don’t like the eggs I made. What would you like instead; I’ll make it for you.” Now, the effective parent would say, “I’m sorry you don’t like what’s for breakfast. You are welcome to make something else that you find more appealing. But I would like you to sit at the table and eat with us.” Now you have included the Limit Setting role of parenting: You expect your child to take responsibility for her breakfast if she doesn’t like what is offered. You do not cross your own boundary of interrupting your own breakfast or doing for her what she can do for herself. And you hold her to the rule of eating together as a family.

But here’s the key—you have also made sure to include the loving side of parenting. You’re not angry if she makes a choice that’s different from yours; you don’t take it personally. You let her decide what she would like to eat and you’re empathetic to her disappointment about the breakfast. You’ve held true to your beliefs without trying to control your child’s feelings or behavior.

Can I change my parenting style?

If you see yourself in either of these two extremes, give yourself a break and understand that it’s very normal for parents to manage anxiety by becoming either too controlling or too passive. If you want to change your parenting style, the first step is recognizing that what you’ve been doing up until now is ineffective. As soon as you’ve done that, you’re already on your way. Committing to doing something different will help change a destructive relationship into a lasting, influential one.

The key is to have a plan and then prepare, predict and act. This means that for each situation that arises, pause and think before reacting. So consider the “rules side” of a situation and ask yourself what limits you want to set. Think through your expectations and identify your bottom line. Predict some ways your child might react and try to come up with a suitable response. Decide what structure and guidance you want to provide—in other words, the rules that need to be followed and the consequences that will be given. At the same time, think about the loving side of parenting. Ask yourself, “How can I set the rules and include empathy, respect and care?”

Here’s an example of an effective conversation you might have with your child using these guidelines:

You: “You’re supposed to make your bed, what happened?
Your child: “I forgot.”
You: “I keep asking you to do your chores and you keep forgetting. Asking over and over doesn’t seem to help. Any suggestions?”
Your child: “I’ll remember next time.”
You: “But you’ve said that before.”
Your child: “No, but this time I promise I will.”
You: “Okay, good. And if you don’t, you will have to stay in on Saturday and do some chores that your dad and I need done around the house.”

You’ve given your child the chance to make the right choice by imposing a structure, but you’ve imposed limits if he makes a poor choice. Another rule of thumb for parents is to ask, “Will this help my child grow into a self–sufficient, caring, independent–thinking adult, or am I doing this to calm my anxiety and distress right now?” Our knee jerk reaction with parenting is usually operating from a place of asking your child to be a certain way so you can feel calm. Instead, think of ways to calm yourself down and help your child to grow up.


Enter your email address to receive our FREE
weekly parenting newsletter.

For more than 25 years, Debbie has offered compassionate and effective therapy and coaching, helping individuals, couples and parents to heal themselves and their relationships. Debbie is the creator of the Calm Parent AM & PM program and is also the author of numerous books for young people on interpersonal relations.

READER'S COMMENTS

Very good article. Well written. Good dialog examples.

Comment By : lovingmotherof six

As a single parent of two teens, I found this to be quite helpful on many levels. I believe, over time, one can lose the sense of self that one has and needs some rerouting from time to time.

Comment By : Tiffanie

Good article. As Josh McDowell says "You can't have rules without relationship." They must all be in balance, this is the hardest part, but gets easier with practice. Carol Parent Coach

Comment By : Carol Parent Coach

Very good article. I struggle though with giving choices to children at the table. We have six children and we fix a meal. To have them say they don't like it and they are free to fix something themselves would be chaotic! We do insist they eat what they are given, however, if they don't like it, we don't put much of that item on their plate. We insist they at least try everything on the table, that everything provided is healthy for them, and that sometimes we have to try things that we don't like to do.

Comment By : Steve

I found this article to be helpful, it was spot on for my situation. Chrystal

Comment By : Chrystal

I agree with Steve. I do not believe it is it up to the children to decide what the menu will be. I think it has become so common in our society to eat out, where each person gets to pick what he/she will eat, that children have come to expect that they have the right to do the same thing at home. However, I do not run a restaurant -- I run a home. I always keep in mind my children's food preferences when making a meal, but I don't let it dictate the final outcome. I offer a variety of choices, but tell them "This is what we are having for dinner. I'd like you to eat a few bites of sweet potatoes, but if you chose not to, please eat plenty of salad. We will not be eating again until breakfast." On occasion, one of them may refuse to eat anything on their plate, but not one of them has ever starved to death before the next meal.

Comment By : Maris

Great article on the hardest job of all: parenting. Thanks for the wonderful examples.

Comment By : krs

My wife is the push over and I am the rules parent. Neither are an extreme example of such, but I am going to share this with her so that perhaps we can meet somewhere in the middle. This should solve our problem of being on 2 different pages. Thanks for the perspective.

Comment By : Bob

If i am this kind of a parent and my son ran away from home with the gothic group from high school three years ago after graduation; will he ever come back to contact me? What can I do when I feel depressed.

Comment By : Kimberly

* Dear Kimberly: We’re sorry to hear your family is going through this. It is important to reach out for help when you feel depressed. There are many treatments available. To know which treatment is appropriate for you, begin at your doctor’s office. To read about the symptoms of depression and the types of treatment available, read this link from the National Institute of Mental Health.

Comment By : Carole Banks, Parental Support Line Advisor

I agree with Steve and Maris.......and if my children decide they don't want to eat their food...they too are reminded that its ok not to eat it all up as force feeding children just because they have to clear their plates is wrong and can lead to problems with weight in later life...... As long as children are given their 5 a day healthy food and snacks and they are healthy and happy don't make food an issue.....

Comment By : Bev

What is the NEXT step when the "stay in on Saturday to do chores solution" doesn't work? Because they won't do those either. And what is the NEXT step after that? Our problem is that so called "logical" consequences have absolutely ZERO effect on long term behaviour.

Comment By : CPColorado

How about offering the bed-forgetting child a visual aid to remember their chores? That seems more effective than just letting them "promise" once again: promising isn't working, let's try something else. Have the child make the visual chart, and place it in a highly visible location.

Comment By : Joeymom

This article has clearly defined my parenting style which is Control Freak. Being a single man raising a daughter causes me anxiety often, so your advice is very much welcomed.

Comment By : Arjay

* Dear CPColorado, It sounds like you are having a really difficult time getting your kids to do their chores. When having kids stay in on the weekends until their chores are done, make sure you allow them to earn free time after the chores are complete. For example, tell them “Once you do these chores, then you may sleep over your friend’s house.” This ensures that you are providing your children some motivation. You might also motivate your children more by offering a weekly allowance. Please refer to these articles for more ideas: "I'll Do It Later!"6 Ways to Get Kids to Do Chores Now, Kids, Chores and Responsibilities: 5 Questions to Help Them Get on Track

Comment By : Sara A. Bean, M.Ed., Parental Support Advisor

I've read "Bob's" comment and am in the same boat except I am the rules parent and my husband the pushover although not extreams either, I will show him this artical too!

Comment By : Lisa S.

Rate this article by clicking the stars below.

Rating: 2.7/5 (116 votes cast)

Related keywords:

control freak, effective parenting, pushover parent

Responses to questions posted on EmpoweringParents.com are not intended to replace qualified medical or mental health assessments. We cannot diagnose disorders or offer recommendations on which treatment plan is best for your family. Please seek the support of local resources as needed. If you need immediate assistance, or if you and your family are in crisis, please contact a qualified mental health provider in your area, or contact your statewide crisis hotline.

We value your opinions and encourage you to add your comments to this discussion. We ask that you refrain from discussing topics of a political or religious nature. Unfortunately, it's not possible for us to respond to every question posted on our website.
If you like "Control Freak vs. Pushover Parenting: Why Neither Works", you might like these related articles: