Login
GLOBAL SEARCH
RELATED ITEMS
 
Why the Word “No” Sets off an Oppositional, Defiant Child (July 2008)
Sick of Your Kid’s Backtalk? Here’s How to Stop It (July 2008)
Temper, Temper: Keeping Your Cool
When Kids Push Your Buttons (June 2008)
Masters of Manipulation: How Kids Control You With Behavior (November 2007)
Managing the Meltdown (July 2007)
The Jekyll and Hyde Child: Targeted Behavior Problems (July 2007)
Oppositional Defiant Disorder: The War at Home (June 2007)
Anger Management 101: The Return of Mean Mommy (blog post)
How I Gave Consequences that Worked (and Lived to Tell the Tale) (blog post)
 
ARTICLES ABOUT
 
 Abusive Behavior (8)
 Accountability (3)
 Acting Out (16)
 Addiction (2)
 Adhd/add (9)
 Adolescent Behavior (6)
 Aggressive Behavior (9)
 Alcohol (3)
 Anger Management (3)
 Annoying Behaviors (1)
 Annoying Teen Behaviors (5)
 
VIEWING OPTIONS:

View as List
View by Issue

EmpoweringParents.com
Recognized as One of the
Best Parenting Websites in 2008
 
Articles
”You’re making me crazy!”
When You’re at the End of Your Parenting Rope
Print Email

Parent: “OK, time to turn off the video games and go clean your room.”
Child: “That’s not fair! I don’t want to clean my room! That’s boring and stupid!”
Parent: “Why do you always do this to me? You’re making me crazy!!!”

When parents say things like, “Why are you doing this to me? You’re making me crazy,” to their children, it’s a signal to me that they’re personalizing their kids’ behavior. In other words, what you’re really doing is taking your child’s behavior and viewing it as a personal attack upon you. In my experience, parents often say things like this when they're at the end of their ropes, emotionally.

But I think parents make a major mistake when they personalize their children’s behavior. Remember that misbehavior and inappropriate language often come from a child’s low tolerance for frustration, fear and anger, and then is combined with their poor problem-solving skills in emotional situations. When parents personalize the inappropriate behavior directed at them, this often leads to fighting with their children, with really nothing to be gained. Remember, we want to avoid power struggles and fights whenever we can.

From a parent’s perspective, when you finally yell in exasperation, “Why are you doing this to me,” what you’re saying is, “Can’t you see you’re hurting me? Can’t you see you’re making me angry?” Of course, the truth is that your child can’t see that they’re hurting you, because children and adolescents generally have very poorly developed empathy skills. So even if your child feels empathy toward a person or an animal, they haven’t always developed the skills necessary to show their empathy by changing their behavior. And empathy itself doesn’t seem to develop at the same pace in everyone. This means that often, when you put your child or adolescent in a position where you’re trying to engage their empathy by saying, “You’re hurting me,” it doesn’t go in their ears the same way it comes out of your mouth. Also you have to consider the fact that empathy is very often not the issue. The issue is that they  want to get back at you for telling them to do something they don’t want to do. And if they know what buttons to push to make you frustrated or angry, they’re going to push them because it gives them a sense of power or control over the situation.

It’s also important to realize that when you ask, “Why do you want to hurt me,” you’re giving your child or adolescent information about how to hurt you later. So the next time there’s a disagreement or you’re locked in a power struggle, your child will use that knowledge to hurt you in order to get you to back off. So when you use a phrase like, “You’re making me crazy,” what your child hears you saying is, “You have tremendous power over me. Oh, your muscles are so big and strong, please don’t hurt me.” By saying this, you’re not engaging your child’s empathy; you’re engaging your kid’s urge to use domination and control as a problem-solving tool. And those tools aren’t effective. They may solve your child’s problems with frustration or anger in the short term, but in the long run, as everyone knows, they don’t work.

So instead of personalizing your child’s behavior by thinking, “Why is he doing this to me,” try to think, “What does he need from me right now?” In some cases, your child may need you to listen to him or her and process whatever they’re going through. In my experience, very often what your child really needs is for you to give clear instruction and set firmer limits: They need you to follow through and be consistent. Don’t show them that you’ve taken what they’ve said personally—keep your comments about feeling attacked to yourself, your partner or a supportive group of friends.

Personalizing kids’ behavior is just not helpful. It won’t lead to solving the real problem for you or your child. And remember, teaching your child problem-solving skills is one of the most important goals you can achieve as a parent.

Print Email

Empowering Parents is a weekly newsletter, online magazine and blog published by Legacy Publishing Company. Our goal is to empower people who parent by providing useful problem-solving techniques to parents and children. The views expressed in the articles on Empowering Parents represent the opinions of the authors and the experts quoted therein. Unfortunately, it’s not possible for us to respond to every question posted after an article on our website. Empowering Parents encourages its readers to participate by weighing in with suggestions and advice. For more information, visit www.empoweringparents.com

James Lehman is a behavioral therapist and the creator of The Total Transformation Program for parents. He has worked with troubled children and teens for three decades. James holds a Masters Degree in Social Work from Boston University. For more information, visit www.thetotaltransformation.com.



READERS' COMMENTS

We are continuing to have curfew issues with our almost 18 year old who is entering her senior year in high school. The rules are; We would like to know where she is and with whom, and don't break curfew (midnight). This summer she leaves at noon for work and we don't see her until curfew. She usually doesn't check in so we call a few times a day. For a while we've been using the "if your late for curfew, you will come in one hour early for three nights to assure us you can do it". Now she's been coming home up to 2 hours late and taking the consequence. I suppose we'll have to lay some time frames into the curfew as well. Your article“You’re making me crazy!” When You're at the End of Your Parenting Rope, rang true for me. I have insomnia issues and so once I'm engaged in feeling angry, worried, upset, these emotions don't allow me drift off into a peaceful sleep even after my teendoes finally roll in. I usually end up yelling at her for being inconsiderate given my sleep issues. Not having "empathy" leaves me feeling even more hurt. Thanks for pointing this out and I will do my best to separate my emotions when talking with her. It will be difficult feeling so tired.
 

I really needed this today. After an eventful day and night yesterday and last night, when my 17 year old son left for school this morning he took personal items and said he wasn't coming back. Although we have always tried not to let him know he hurts us and tried to be there for him and listen to him, nothing seems to work. We just get cursed out all the time and blamed for eveything. Even though our children have always been our main priority. We are just lost.
 

this article is right on, this incident happen to me last evening, I basicly was so tired of his ODD that I was just like this. Is there an article about problem solving skills. Is it to late to teach him now, apparently I have not done a good job of it so far.
 

Not only did I ask, "Why are you hurting me and why are you making me angry?" but I had to go and compound the error by also adding, "When you are 54 years old and a 7 year old kid does this to you, I want you to think back to this moment and remember how you treated me!" I mean, as I was saying this, I was also telling myself to shut up but I was wonkey! Now I am laughing at myself and feeling powerful again to go back into the ring and try again, this time to be more successful. Keep 'em coming James! We need you out here in the trenches.
 

This article rings so true to my life right now... maybe i am just feeling the end of summer blues... ready for the kids to be gone, but also anxious about the new schedules and time constraints we will have to follow again... my biggest error is saying to my 9 year old son "are you acting this way because you want to drive me crazy?" I can honestly say i have said this one too many times the past few weeks. My 9 year old finally said to me, "Momma why do you say such hurtful things to me?"... what a eye opener... and NOW to know that I have given him more power makes me feel even more frustrated as a mom because I am making mistakes OVER and OVER and OVER in the parenting book. Thanks for the articles James... keep 'em coming... God knows I need all the advice I can get these days.
 

Thank you so much for this article. My 7-year-old has ADHD (mostly ADD), and I was actually in tears last night because I couldn't get him to finish his homework. I know better, but I just couldn't stop. Then, after allowing him to go to bed at 8:00 instead of 9:00, he wanted to get back up at 8:15 and try to finish. He made a little bit of progress, and the "down time" gave both of us a break. I need to keep remembering that he's not doing it "to" me and that's he's just as frustrated as I am. Thanks for the articles. They have been EXTREMELY helpful and are always right on target at just the right time!!!
 

Sorry. My child is 9, not 7. He was not allowed to stay up until 9:00 when he was 7 years old!!
 

wow this counld not have came at a better time. my son is 10 years old and I struggle with getting him to do what I say. he tells me that im the meanest mom ever or he does not like me. and I in return say why are you doing this to me. I go thru this everyday. and Im at the end of my rope. reading this article gives me hope thank you so much for sharin this information with us.
 

My wife and I have been struggling with our 17 year old son for the past two years. We have found a really good counselor who mirrors what your articles are saying. As far as curfew issues, he helped us tremendously during the summer. Our son refused to be home at the set curfew so we began locking the doors at the set curfew time and told him that when he decides to disobey the curfew rule that he can find a cot and sleeping bag out on the back patio. The first time he decided to test our consequence was a particularly nasty weather night and he did not enjoy not being able to sleep in his own bed. He tested the consequence about 2 or 3 more times by either crashing at his friends house (which he was only allowed by the friend's parents one time) or by having to sleep outside under the patio. By mid-July he was never late again and has not argued the consequence since we stood our ground (which was difficult). One other thing we have learned reflects this article, we don't try to personalize his meaness and disrespect, we simply remind him that our morals and upbringing do not appreciate his attitude towards us and others and that we will not tolerate it. We remind him that if he chooses to continue to disregard our attempts to teach him the difference between right and wrong behavoir and wants to treat us as he does that we can have him leave the house when we are not home (by locking him out) and that he is welcome back in at night (but not after curfew, of course). Our defense has had to go to these extremes at times, but we find that he really has to think about how HE is leaving us with little or no choice. We always remind him that we LOVE HIM but not his unacceptable behavior.
 

My 20 y/o son is now out of the house which is good since he quit his job one month ago & his dad still doesn't know. However, he still has magical thinking about getting a high paying job without a college education. Your article points out correctly that have given him way too much power over me. I have allowed him to put me in the middle of his dad & i. Now, how do I get out of this?
 

With three teens at home (girls 13 and 15) and a son just turned 18, I can totally relate to this feeling. I've had issues mostly with my son, (hopefully the girls have learned how NOT to behave from watching their brother and seeing the effects it's had on me and the rest of the family.) The hardest thing for me now is that my boyfriend recently moved (we've been together three years) and though my son is polite to him, he's still very rude and angry towards me. So I get it from the son and he leaves; then I get a lecture on how I need to "control" my son from my boyfriend (who, at 50, never had any children of his own.) At a time when I really need my boyfriend's support and understanding of how hurt I feel when my son is mean to me...instead I am told how it is "all my fault." My son is very strong-willed and I've had difficulty reigning him in since he was a very young boy. I feel guilty and heartbroken enough having to tell my son to go live with his father if he can't abide by the rules in my home; the LAST thing I need is my boyfriend blaming me for my son's bad behavior. It's like he's talking out of both sides of his mouth--If my son is truly an adult and "responsible for his own behavior" then HOW the hell is this MY fault? I feel angry and hurt and resentful toward the two "men" in my life that I love the most!
 

I have a 7 year old son and e was recently diagnosed with adhd. He was on ritulin and now he is on concerta. H has a very bad temper.Constantly getting into trouble in school by suspension and he has trouble keeping his hands to himself.Alot of his teachers do not understand him and treats him so mean.He said that he has been to P E once since school started. His gym teacher is so hard on him and I feel that he needs gym to vent his frustrations and burn his energy out .He also urinate on himself when he is upset and gets in trouble.He has been wrote up on the school bus and it hurts me to see that I am trying so hard for him and the professionals [educators] are not caring no matter how many meetings I go to. He is very smart an A student but the only problem is his behaviour and it makes me feel so frustrated and I sometimes feel like I am losing my mind.Sometimes after talking to him I have to go take aspirin because I feel like I am having a heart attack.I look forward to a bad report everyday and I also reward for every time he is deserving of it but it does not help for long.
 

I guess it is just a power struggle, bur I am afraid sometimes that I am too controlling for a 17 year old, that they may need to feel independent and may resent me forever if I push too much
 

I too have a child who tests my limits ...daily!!!! He is 9 years old and I also home school him. As a single mom I feel like running away some times. I suspect he is ODD.He hits me, punches me, and bites me when he gets upset. He respects no rules I set in the house. He will not play with the other children in the neighborhood. I feel like i live with my abusive ex husband all over again!He has no respect for any adults...period. I laid in bed one day a couple of weeksago and told him he had to be sent way somewhere because I give up! I told him that there were no longer any rules to follow and he could do what he wanted to. He freaked out and began to beg to have the rules back. So I know he wants guidance and direction. I asked him why he does what he does and he just started crying and answered, "I don't know." I feel so sad about all this. I love him so much this is tearing me up inside. He can be so kind and loving, where is that baby I knew not so long ago? What is happening to our children> Why are they acting like monsters? If I can't find something that works< I will have to send him to Military school or something to save my sanity!!!!
 

I too have a child who tests my limits ...daily!!!! He is 9 years old and I also home school him. As a single mom I feel like running away some times. I suspect he is ODD.He hits me, punches me, and bites me when he gets upset. He respects no rules I set in the house. He will not play with the other children in the neighborhood. I feel like i live with my abusive ex husband all over again!He has no respect for any adults...period. I laid in bed one day a couple of weeksago and told him he had to be sent way somewhere because I give up! I told him that there were no longer any rules to follow and he could do what he wanted to. He freaked out and began to beg to have the rules back. So I know he wants guidance and direction. I asked him why he does what he does and he just started crying and answered,"I don't know." I feel so sad about all this. I love him so much this is tearing me up inside. He can be so kind and loving, where is that baby I knew not so long ago? What is happening to our children> Why are they acting like monsters? If I can't find something that works, I will have to send him to Military school or something to save my sanity!!!!
 


 
 

Rate this article by clicking the stars below.

Rating: 4.0/5 (20 votes cast)

* All fields are mandatory.
Submit Comment:


Your Email (Will not be shown):


Screen Name (Will appear next to comment):


Please enter the text in the image:
captcha image  




Your comment will be posted after it is approved by the EP site administrator.
 
 

 

* Responses to questions posted on EmpoweringParents.com are not intended to replace qualified medical or mental health assessments. We cannot diagnose disorders or offer recommendations on which treatment plan is best for your family. Please seek the support of local resources as needed. If you need immediate assistance, or if you and your family are in crisis, please contact a qualified mental health provider in your area, or contact your
statewide crisis hotline.



 
NEWSLETTER SIGNUP
Enter your email address to receive our weekly newsletter
View Email Archive
 
LATEST EP NEWS
 
Empowering Parents Helps Parents Survive Summer Vacation
EmpoweringParents.com Wins Prestigious iParenting Media Award for "Best Products of 2008"
New Empowering Parents Blog Provides Weekly Insights for Parents in Crisis
More...
 
SPONSORED LINKS
©2008 Legacy Publishing Company. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Link to Us
Manage my Subscription | Unsubscribe Here | Whitelisting EP