Why Consequences Aren't Enough, Part 2 Making Child Behavior Changes That Last

by Sara Bean, M.Ed.
Why Consequences Aren't Enough, Part 2 Making Child Behavior Changes That Last

Ever wonder why your child continues to misbehave, no matter what you do? You may be skipping some critical steps in parenting. Don’t miss part two of our series on why consequences alone aren’t enough to change your child’s behavior.

There’s no such thing as a perfect consequence that will make your child’s behavior “magically” change. Rather, there are effective and ineffective consequences. Ineffective consequences teach your child how to do time—how to be grounded for a few weeks, or how to live without his video games or cell phone. Effective consequences have two main goals: to teach your child and to hold him accountable. It’s a very important distinction, and could mean the difference between seeing change or becoming frustrated and resentful about your child’s behavior.

"Parents who are effective limit setters also limit themselves. They have limits on how they react to unwanted behaviors—and what they will react to at all."

In addition to giving effective consequences, in The Total Transformation, James Lehman says that you need to play three main roles as a parent: the Trainer/Coach, the Problem Solver, and the Limit Setter. In the first part of this series on Empowering Parents, I explained how the Trainer/Coach role works. Today I’m going to tell you how to take on the all-important Problem Solver role and the powerful Limit Setter role. Understand that these three roles work together and often overlap, but don’t let this intimidate you—they absolutely can be learned and practiced until they come to you naturally. On the Parental Support Line, I work with parents every day to teach them how to use all three to become more effective and help change their children’s behavior.

Related: Change your child’s behavior with these techniques.

The Problem Solver Role

The Problem Solver role is quite similar to the Trainer/Coach, though its emphasis is more on using problem-solving to develop new skills. The Problem Solver focuses on setting goals and identifying the obstacles that are in the way. In this role, you might help your child to anticipate future problems and discuss how he can solve them before they happen. For example, you might say, “Someone will offer you drugs some day. What will you say? Here’s what you can do...” As a problem solver, you’ll talk about your expectations of your child in a clear, specific way. So for example, instead of saying, “Be a good boy in the grocery store today,” the problem solver parent would say, “We’re going to the store to get the things on our list. I expect you not to ask for anything and to keep your hands to yourself inside the cart instead of grabbing stuff off the shelves.” Additionally, the Problem Solver parent is open to trying new rules and letting their child have a chance to earn an age-appropriate amount of independence while engaging him in the process. For example, let’s say your 16-year-old daughter wants a later curfew—she wants to come in at 11:30 p.m. instead of 11:00. You might say, “You can’t even make it home at 11, and you want me to let you stay out even later? I don’t think so!” But the problem solving parent would begin by finding out why your daughter isn’t making it home on time right now. What’s the problem? The Problem Solver would say, “I understand you want a later curfew, but you seem to be struggling to get home by 11. What’s going on? What’s keeping you from being home on time?” And then talk about what she can do differently to make curfew. You have to identify the problem before we can find a solution.

Once you talk about the problem and find a new solution, you might tell your daughter that you’re going to try an 11:30 p.m. curfew if she comes home on time at 11 p.m. for the next week. Let her know exactly what you need to see in order for her to achieve that goal. “Coming home on time for the next seven days,” is specific and observable. You also let her know what will happen if it goes well: You’ll let her keep the new curfew. If it doesn’t go well, you’ll go back to the 11 p.m. curfew for the time being.

Related: Tired of backtalk and disrespect?

The Limit Setter Role

The Limit Setter parent sets limits and rules and follows through without justifying himself, defending his actions or over-explaining to the child. For example, if your child is challenging you about his driving privileges and wants to drive three of his friends to a place somewhere outside of town, using the Limit Setter role you would respond in a calm and businesslike way, stating, “You can’t drive your friends to another town and you can’t have more than one friend in the car at a time. That’s the rule until you have more experience behind the wheel.”  Then, you’ll walk away if your child argues, begs, or pleads. So essentially, effective limit setters also limit themselves. They have limits on how they react to unwanted behaviors—and what they will react to at all. They ignore bad attitudes and don’t try to force their child into compliance by constantly reminding, nagging, pushing, threatening or “doing” for the child. The effective limit setter won’t cross that line because they know it doesn’t work. Rather, they expect compliance and they hold their kids accountable when they don’t comply.

By compliance, I mean that your child is doing the task you asked him to do: the dishwasher is being unloaded, the chores are getting done or he’s going to his room. Pay no mind if he has a scowl on his face or if he’s stomping his feet or mumbling under his breath—this is the attitude piece that we need to ignore. So as James Lehman says in The Total Transformation Program, “You’re not there to prevent your kid from doing things, you’re there to deal with what he does and hold him accountable.” Your current goal might be to make your child do his homework every night at any cost. If so, realize that this mindset isn’t going to work. Instead, your focus should be on setting a standard and holding your child accountable to that. What this might look like is: no electronics each night until your teen has studied for an hour first. If he doesn’t do his homework, he doesn’t get to play video games or video chat with his friends that day, and he can try again tomorrow. This is how you hold your child accountable. Understand that if you set that standard and you don’t follow through—if you let him play his video games before his work is done—your child learns that your words and limits are meaningless.

Related: How to give effective consequences and follow through on them.

Let me be clear that there are exceptions. If you make a poor choice and give a really ineffective consequence out of anger, you don’t have to follow through on that. Let’s say your child has come in late, and you tell him that he’s not allowed to go out for the rest of the summer. The cost might be worse than the benefit, and what’s more, it’s not effective. So you can acknowledge your mistake, give a new consequence that’s more effective, and follow through on that one instead.

Using the 3 Parenting Roles: What Kind of Pushback Can You Expect?

You might be wondering, “Once I’m practicing these three parenting roles fairly consistently, what changes can I expect to see?” Initially most parents can expect their kids to be pretty unhappy. When you stop explaining yourself or engaging in power struggles with your kids, it can be really upsetting for them and hard for them to adjust to. So recognize that resistance is normal. Your child will test you to see if you really are changing, or if they can get you to go back to your old ways instead. After all, they were the ones in control back then. They could drive you crazy, make you scream and get you to give in by acting out of control. Imagine how powerful they must have felt! Now as they see you changing, they might follow you around, badger you, talk back, and try to push your buttons. But the key is to walk away and let your kids know their behavior is not going to get them what they want. Don’t adjust your standards based on their emotional state or ugly behavior. Remind yourself that you can get through this initial escalation; things will get better if you stay calm and consistent in the face of your child’s anger and resistance.

I want to make an important note here: if your child’s behavior escalates to hurting someone else in the home, hurting themselves, becoming destructive or violent, or even threatening to hurt themselves or someone else, we recommend that you consider calling the police to ensure everyone’s safety. In some cases, it’s also necessary for parents to have support from someone locally, such as a counselor or family therapist, to work through this escalation period in a safe way that’s appropriate for your child.

Creating a Culture of Accountability

Once you become a more experienced Trainer/Coach, Problem Solver and Limit Setter, you will gradually see your child’s self esteem getting better; his attitude may even improve in the bargain. In The Total Transformation, James Lehman says that, “You can’t feel your way to better behavior; you have to behave your way to better feelings.” He felt that the key to self esteem is for your child to learn to do things that are hard. That’s why improved self esteem is another product of effective parenting, because you’re teaching your child how to do things that are hard.

Another byproduct of using the three effective parenting roles is that you’re going to create a “Culture of Accountability” in your home. What does this mean exactly? It means that the more you hold your child accountable for his behaviors, the more he’ll learn. He’ll find that blaming others doesn’t get him out of his responsibilities, that kicking and screaming in the store doesn’t get him what he wants, that putting chores off doesn’t get him out of doing them, and that being verbally abusive or destructive doesn’t make his curfew later. It’s a long process, but your child will eventually learn that he’s responsible for his behavior and that you’ll hold him accountable if he doesn’t step up and take responsibility on his own. With time and practice, this can gradually become the culture in your home.

Will things ever be perfect? Probably not. After all, life is always giving us new problems to solve. But now, you’ll have the skills as a parent to get your family through the challenges you face along the way.

Enter your email address to receive our FREE
weekly parenting newsletter.

Sara A. Bean, M.Ed. holds a Masters Degree in Education with a concentration in School Counseling from Florida Atlantic University. She is a Certified School Counselor and a proud aunt to a 5 year-old girl. She has been with Legacy Publishing since 2009 working on the Parental Support Line. Sara has over 5 years of experience working with youth and families in private homes, residential group homes, and schools.


Excellent article, and the part about following you around and trying to push your buttons - so accurate! I try to remember my old conflict resolution training, when they talk LOUDER and FASTER, I talk LOWER and SLOWER, just keep saying to yourself "low and slow" as you walk away.

Comment By : Church Saufley

My 14 y.o. is dealing with the consequences of poor choices from a year ago when he failed his 7th grade history class. Since then he was accepted into a pilot high school, but in order for him to attend, he has to go to summer school and complete the history requirement. So far he has had to give up a sleep over and now a week with his dad at the beach house, which his sister gets to go to.

Comment By : luvmykidz

"You’re not there to prevent your kid from doing things, you’re there to deal with what he does and hold him accountable.” - This is a very profound statement and I couldn't agree more. I hope parents don't skim over this little nugget of truth. If we see our role as solely the "preventer of bad behavior," we will go to great lengths to achieve it. And as a result, our children will have no motivation to change. Thanks for this great reminder.

Comment By : Cornerstones for Parents

I found this article to be thought provoking and exciting. As an administrator that deals with discipline daily, these strategies will hopefully help middle school students change their behavior. As a parent of a 5 month old, I am excited to know that there are some additional guidelines (outside of the biblical principles that I will use). I look forward to more.

Comment By : HoneyBear

I should finish my comment about my 14 y.o.: although he isn't happy about having to attend summer school or missing out on the beach house, he understands the consequences and is taking them in stride. It's taken him nearly 3 long years to come to this point. I'm very proud of him. I read these articles faithfully and have learned so much with how to deal with his ADD and the bahaviors associated with them. Like I said, he was accepted into a pilot school which concentrates on math, science, and technology. I hope he does well and he is very excited to be attending, so this bump in the summer road is worth it to him in the long run. Thank you EP!!

Comment By : luvmykidz

Wow! This should come with a child's birth certificate the world would definitely be a better place!

Comment By : 5339kim

I got TTP 3 yrs ago when my tyrannical teen was 14.She had reported me to child services and my EX for physically stopping her from abusing her younger sib. She is now a highschool grad with a Double Dogwood certificate for french immersion, has a got herSELF a gr8 summer job and will start her post secondary in the fall. I know what we have put into her since birth & the TTP helped keep me/us focused and on track TOGETHER as parents raising our kids in seperate house-holds! Thank you J.L amarie04

Comment By : amarie04

I like this article. I found it very insightful and will bare in mind some of the tips you mentioned. Thank you for sharing it with us.

Comment By : Rhys Klu

I find your articles very useful and interesting, and I am trying to work on being a more effective parent. I have spent a lot of time beating myself up for being a bad parent, and realise now that it is not useful or constructive. My son had a pretty bad year this year, for various reasons, but still managed to pass the year not too badly. Next year, however, he needs to improve his grades considerably to be able to get into university - I am trying to work out how best to support him in this, knowing that if I push too hard, he pushes back and digs his heels in and it becomes counter productive. some advice would be great.

Comment By : BGS

* To BGS: Sometimes it can be tough to find the balance between pushing too hard for your child to change, and giving enough support for them to make the change for themselves. We recommend starting off talking with your son in a calm, neutral manner about expectations for the next year, and what he can do differently this year to meet those goals. You might also consider asking him if there’s something you can do to help him, such as double checking his homework. I am including a link to an article I think you might find helpful: http://www.empoweringparents.com/9-Back-to-School-Tips-for-Parents.php?&key=School-And-Homework 9 Back to School Behavior Tips: How to Set Up a Structure That Works Good luck to you and your son as you continue to work through this.

Comment By : Rebecca Wolfenden, Parental Support Line Advisor

I don't have out of control kids or kids that are abusive and mean. They are very sweet kids, 10 and 11. Our only problem is lying over the dumbest things, like brushing teeth, doing homework or chores, taking the dog out. It seems like it has become a habit. Our Consequence/Reward chart doesn't even motivate them to tell the truth. It doesn't seem to be effective at all. I am at a loss. If it wasn't such simple things I don't think I would be as bothered. What do I do??

Comment By : Kaye

Almost three weeks ago my 4 1/2 year old son got into a scuffle with his cousin and in the process of shaking his fist at his cousin...his cousin went forward and my son inadvertently made contact with his cousins mouth. Even though we knew it wasn't intentional we held him accountable because had he not made the motion of punching his cousin it wouldn't have happened in the first place. We told him to apologize which he refused. We told him he could not play with the brand new leap pad he had gotten the day before until he apologized. Three weeks later no apology and no leap pad. So now what? He has said that apologizing makes him feel scared and makes his "tummy feel funny". I thanked him for telling me how he felt and said I understand how hard it is, empathized with his feelings.. we did role play where we pretended to bump into each other and then say "oops, I'm sorry". but seriously??? now what?? If I give back his leap pad without the apology it goes against following through but it feels more like a control at this point. Is he really just that good at waiting me out? When I ask him about it, he says "you'll forget mommy" meaning Ill forget and let him play and he'll wait for then instead of having to make the apology..

Comment By : jacksmom

* To “jacksmom”: Thank you for asking such a great question. Holding your child accountable can feel like a waiting game between you and your child. At this point, it probably isn’t going to be effective to stay in the waiting game, especially with a child this age. When thinking about how to hold a child accountable, it may be helpful to ask yourself what you want your son to learn from this situation. If you want him to learn more appropriate ways of interacting with his cousin, you might consider having a problem-solving conversation with your son and talk about what he will do differently next time. After he has the conversation, he can earn his leap pad back. It sounds like you have done an excellent job role playing with him ways he can respond differently. Since he has already had this conversation with you in the form of role playing, it’s OK for him to earn the Leap Pad back. Here are a couple articles that go over problem solving you may find useful: Good Behavior is not “Magic”—It’s a Skill The Three Skills Every Child Needs for Good Behavior & The Surprising Reason for Bad Child Behavior: "I Can't Solve Problems". If he exhibits inappropriate behavior in the future, we would advise continuing with setting limits around appropriate behavior and problem solving/role playing, as you have done here. We hope this is helpful for you and wish you luck as you work through this challenge. Take care.

Comment By : D. Rowden, Parental Support Advisor

Rate this article by clicking the stars below.

Rating: 2.9/5 (135 votes cast)

Related keywords:

accountability, setting limits, problem solving, consequences, effective parenting, behavior changes

Responses to questions posted on EmpoweringParents.com are not intended to replace qualified medical or mental health assessments. We cannot diagnose disorders or offer recommendations on which treatment plan is best for your family. Please seek the support of local resources as needed. If you need immediate assistance, or if you and your family are in crisis, please contact a qualified mental health provider in your area, or contact your statewide crisis hotline.

We value your opinions and encourage you to add your comments to this discussion. We ask that you refrain from discussing topics of a political or religious nature. Unfortunately, it's not possible for us to respond to every question posted on our website.
If you like "Why Consequences Aren't Enough, Part 2 Making Child Behavior Changes That Last", you might like these related articles: